Modérateurs: Staff Univers Casques, Staff Haute-Fidélité, Staff Juridique • Utilisateurs parcourant ce forum: Aucun utilisateur enregistré et 25 invités

Discussions sur le matériel Haute-Fidélité

Tuner analogique : toujours valable

Message » 13 Juil 2006 22:16

Que pensez-vous d'acheter aujourd'hui un tuner analogique HDG d'occasion quand on sait que le DAB est opérationnel depuis quelques années ou qu'un nouveau standard va remplacer ce dernier ?
Si c'est encore valable, quels modèles sont intéressants : magnum dynalab (MD100, MD102, FT101A ...), accuphase (T109), luxman, meridian (104, 504), naim (NAT5), revox, kenwood ...

merci pour votre aide car on trouve des tuners à partir de 15 euros en occasion.

J'espère que DUB apportera sa contribution. :wink:
doudou_78
 
Messages: 2215
Inscription: 04 Avr 2005 20:50
Localisation: La Bretagne sous le soleil
  • offline

Annonce

Message par Google » 13 Juil 2006 22:16

Publicite

 
Encart supprimé pour les membres HCFR

Message » 13 Juil 2006 22:33

Toujours valables et toujours beaux!!

Ne pas oublier les Sansui(TU ....) dans ta liste !! 8)

http://www.fmtunerinfo.com/
fargo
 
Messages: 7624
Inscription: 15 Avr 2005 23:01
Localisation: Tolosa
  • offline

Message » 14 Juil 2006 8:28

Voici le classement des tuners selon fmtunerinfo :

1 PLUS: -C- Accuphase T-109V - Very natural sound, good bass. Pinpoint imaging. Lifelike, three-dimensional sound, smooth extended highs.
1 (TIE): -C- Kenwood L-02T - Most natural sound, good bass. Pinpoint imaging. Lifelike, three-dimensional sound.
1 (TIE): -C- Burmester 978 - Natural, open and airy sound, good bass. Pinpoint imaging. Lifelike, three-dimensional sound with nice extended highs.
4: -C- Sansui TU-919 - The prince who could be king.
5: -C- Sansui TU-X1 - Very good sound top to bottom. Big soundstage, three-dimensional. Very slight diffuse sound.
6: -C- Audiolab 8000T - Good bass, natural but diffuse sound, sweet extended highs.
7: -C- Philips AH6731 - A very natural, neutral sound. Stereo separation best with a good signal.
8: -C- Revox B760 - Great bass, lifelike midrange and extended highs.

9: -M- Mitsubishi DA-F20 - Quick, punchy bass, open, lively midrange and extended highs.
10: -M- Kenwood KT-5020 - Great bass and midrange and extended, sweet treble. Again, why pay more?
11: -M- Kenwood KT-990D - Smooth, clean sound that always pleased. Why pay more?
12: -M- Meridian Model 104 - Excellent, natural sound, good bass, no to DX games.
13: -M- Meridian Model 504 - Good bass, excellent midrange with smooth, just-right highs.
14: -M- Kenwood L-1000T - Good bass, punchy midrange, sweet extended highs.
15: -M- Sansui TU-X701 - Great-sounding midrange, bass OK, softer highs next to the L-02T.
16: -M- Luxman T-117 - Very good-sounding tuner. No real faults, top to bottom. Not as three-dimensional as the L-02T and gives up some bass richness.
17: -M- Sansui TU-717 - Good bass and midrange with nice "depth" to the soundstage. More forward than the L-02T.
18: -M- B&K TS-108 - Very nice midrange, good bass and nice, extended highs.
19: -M- Technics ST-9038 - Very good bass, nice midrange, smooth treble.
20: -M- Magnum Dynalab MD-108 - Bass OK, very good imaging and realistic midrange, extended but forward highs.
21: -M- Kenwood KT-917 - Good bass, midrange and treble. A very pleasant sound but more one-dimensional when placed next to the L-02T.
22: -M- Sansui TU-S9 - Smooth, natural sound. A budget bargain.
23: -M- Kenwood KT-1100 - Quite tuneful, but flatter soundstage than the L-02T.
24: -M- McIntosh MR 80 - Good bass, lively midrange and pleasant highs. More one-dimensional than the L-02T.
25: -M- Sanyo Plus T35 - Good bass, laidback midrange and extended, pleasant highs.
26: -M- Technics ST-G7 - Very nice bass, articulate midrange, forward but nice upper range.
27: -M- Pioneer F-99X - Follows behind the big bass dogs but the midrange and treble are where it's at. Sweet, clean, quiet and to be copied.
28: -M- Kenwood KT-3300D - Very good bass, slightly diffuse light mids and pleasant extended highs. A laidback, nice listen.
29: -M- Pioneer F-90 - Great sonics with a slightly lighter sonic presentation than the top dogs. Upper midrange and treble are top-notch.
30: -M- Sansui TU-D99X - Good bass. Bass, midrange and treble work well together for a balanced sound.
31: -M- Hitachi FT-007 - Clean, balanced sound, but less dynamic than the L-02T.
32: -M- Sony ST-J88B - Good bass, pleasing midrange, slightly forward and sweet treble.
33: -M- Linn Kremlin - OK bass; articulate, precise sound; good high frequency. Midrange, bass loses some natural warmth.
34: -M- Restek Metric - Excellent imaging, bass and highs. Midrange gave up some to other tuners.
35: -M- Onix TU39 - Dynamic, smooth, the midrange give up some "life" to others. Some added sparkle in the highs.
36: -M- Perreaux TU-3 - Nice balanced sound. Gives up some richness and dynamics to the L-02T.
37: -M- Magnum Dynalab FT-101 - Good all-around sound, treble very slightly forward.
38: -M- Kenwood L-07TII - Good all-around sound but loses some inner detail.
39: -M- Accuphase T-109 - Great bass, dry midrange, pleasant but slightly forward treble.
40: -M- Magnum Dynalab FT-101A Etude - A good, balanced sound, but slightly dry.
41: -M- Technics ST-8077 - Good bass, midrange OK. Nice treble presentation.
42: -M- Technics ST-8080 - Good bass, good midrange, forward highs but not unpleasant.
43: -M- Nikko Gamma V - Very good bass, good imaging, treble forward but not unpleasant.
44: -M- Kenwood KT-8300 - Good bass and dynamics, with a slightly forward upper midrange and treble.
45: -M- Onkyo T-4500 - Slightly lighter but a pleasing sound. Neutral, top to bottom, with nice highs.
46: -M- Onkyo T-9090II - Pleasant sound, good bass, but not as dynamic as some tuners. Great DX machine.
47: -M- NAD 4155 - Good, punchy bass. Light, articulate mids with well-mated highs.
48: -M- Pioneer F-91 - Very good bass punch and control, articulate midrange with forward highs. May be a good tuner for a large room.
49: -M- Pioneer TX-9800 - Rich bass presentation. Good midrange with a treble slightly forward that took away from the total picture.
50: -M- Tandberg 3011A - Good bass, midrange a little light, sweet treble. Very good imaging.
51: -M- Sansui TU-417 - A most pleasant sound, bottom to top. Needs good signals.
52: -M- Carver TX-11b - Punchy bass, clean highs and treble.
53: -M- Sumo Charlie - Punchy bass, good midrange, slightly rolled-off treble.
54: -M- Revox B260 - Rich bass and lower midrange. Good imaging. Three-dimensional. The highs are a little too much for my personal taste. The high rating reflects its other positive sound qualities.
55: -M- Yamaha CT-7000 - Warm-sounding bass, pleasant midrange and highs. Highs a little rolled-off.
56: -M- Sequerra Model 1 - Harmonically rich bass and lower midrange. Very seductive, but if you want accuracy, shop elsewhere.
57: -M- Magnum Dynalab FT-11 "NEW" - Good sound, natural midrange, treble nice, loose bass.
58: -M- Kenwood KT-7300 - Punchy bass, pleasant mids and highs. Slight loss of ambience.
59: -M- Onkyo T-4310R - Pleasant, inoffensive sound, good imaging. Good digital DXing tuner.
60: -M- Magnum Dynalab FT-101A - Pleasant light, airy sound. Lacks bass dynamics.
61: -M- Realistic TM-1001 - Sweet treble, pleasant mids, but the bass is not as full and dynamic as the big dogs.
62: -M- Yamaha T-2 - Very pleasant and listenable. This may be the cutoff tuner between the keepers and the also-rans.

63: Revox B261 - Punchy bass, pleasant enough but slightly forward mids and highs.
64: Pioneer TX-9500II - Clean, articulate sound. Lighter sonic presentation against the L-02T.
65: SAE Mark VI - Inoffensive sound, good background music. A mini-Sequerra.
66: Denon TU-850 - Good sound, midrange just right, treble sweet, slightly bass-shy.
67: Sansui TU-217 - Good sound when reception is strong.
68: Kenwood L-01T - Good sound, midrange slightly forward, good bass.
69: Phase Linear Model 5000 Series Two - Bass-shy, pleasant midrange and treble.
70: Magnum Dynalab FT-11 "OLD" - Good bass, dry midrange, treble OK.
71: Quad FM4 - Very nice midrange, good resolution, extended treble, rolled off bass.
72: Technics ST-9030 - Inoffensive but bland.
73: Naim NAT 01 - Bass OK, midrange OK, treble sweet.
74: Luxman T-115 - Good bass, midrange OK, treble slightly forward.
75: Nakamichi ST-7 - Muffled bass, forward midrange, highs soft and inoffensive.
76: Marantz 2130 - OK bass, midrange and treble forward and "light" sounding.
77: McIntosh MR 78 - Good bass, slightly electronic sound.
78: Fanfare FT-1A - Best through the low-output jacks, clean but bright midrange, lacks bass power.
79: Kenwood KT-7500 - Flat soundstage, better sound can be found. One-note bass. More boring than unpleasant in a long listening session.
80: Cambridge Audio T500 - Bass light, midrange forward and lacks focus, highs OK.
81: Kyocera T-910 - Pleasant sound, but what's that ringing in my ears?
82: SAE 8000 - Not irritating but not involving, either. Too much background noise.
83: Kenwood KT-815 - Bass thin, treble forward. It cries out for a new audio stage.
84: Denon TU-600 - Good sound, but not recommended because of reception problems.


Je suis assez surpris que le Meridian 104 soit supérieur au Magnum MD108.
doudou_78
 
Messages: 2215
Inscription: 04 Avr 2005 20:50
Localisation: La Bretagne sous le soleil
  • offline

Message » 14 Juil 2006 19:36

doudou_78 a écrit:Je suis assez surpris que le Meridian 104 soit supérieur au Magnum MD108.

Pourquoi ? Tes écoutes t'ont laissé penser le contraire ?
angus2
 
Messages: 5932
Inscription: 09 Déc 2003 14:18
Localisation: Paris
  • offline

Message » 14 Juil 2006 19:58

J ai acquis récemment un Marantz 2100, ca change bien du tuner intégré à un ampli HC ;)
highway_
 
Messages: 1886
Inscription: 17 Déc 2002 18:50
Localisation: 91

Message » 16 Juil 2006 14:28

angus2 a écrit:
doudou_78 a écrit:Je suis assez surpris que le Meridian 104 soit supérieur au Magnum MD108.

Pourquoi ? Tes écoutes t'ont laissé penser le contraire ?


je n'ai écouté ni l'un ni l'autre mais d'un point de vue prix, le MD 108 coute environ 4000 euros, le méridian 104 se vend une poignée de cerises.

Comme dit Ali Baba, "les fruits sont chers cette année".

Doudou
doudou_78
 
Messages: 2215
Inscription: 04 Avr 2005 20:50
Localisation: La Bretagne sous le soleil
  • offline

Message » 17 Juil 2006 12:30

Les joies du marché de le HiFi. :lol:
angus2
 
Messages: 5932
Inscription: 09 Déc 2003 14:18
Localisation: Paris
  • offline

Message » 17 Juil 2006 13:42

A ce propos... ça n'est peut-être pas tout à fait l'endroit approprié, mais bon :
(modéré par peperealexis. ce n'est effectivement pas l'endroit approprié, c'est considéré comme une petite annonce, il faut être adhérent pour poster une PA, et dans le forum approprié). :wink:
Le Mulhousien
 
Messages: 35
Inscription: 10 Juil 2006 16:29
Localisation: Mulhouse
  • offline

Message » 17 Juil 2006 23:17

Un travail de fou sur ce site ...mais au fait ils ont oublié de classer le T 1000 d'accuphase ....
chsmits
 
Messages: 635
Inscription: 27 Mai 2004 19:59
Localisation: Paris
  • offline



Retourner vers Discussions Générales

 
  • Articles en relation
    Dernier message