Modérateurs: Modération Forum DIY, Modération Forum Installations, Le Bureau de l’Association HCFR • Utilisateurs parcourant ce forum: Dagda, Greg Lagarrigue, Nixma et 114 invités

Discussions générales sur le DIY Audio : choix des HP, comparaisons des principes : clos vs BR, etc

Scan-speak D6600 vs D6620

Message » 15 Mar 2014 14:18

any body has compared these two tweeters ?
i must choice between them.

thank you
gandalf_77
 
Messages: 12
Inscription Forum: 20 Fév 2005 11:36
  • offline

Message » 15 Mar 2014 14:25

gandalf_77 a écrit:any body has compared these two tweeters ?
i must choice between them.

thank you


Faceplate apart, they are the same. I wonder if the different face plate, has any acoustical influence on this tweeter. The only thing that I can say, that the regular 6600 is a very nice tweeter on my illumina 66.

La configuration dans mon profil


Intoxiqué au Beryllium :D
Powerdoc
Modérateur Home-Cinéma
Modérateur Home-Cinéma
 
Messages: 7907
Inscription Forum: 30 Sep 2006 19:05
Localisation: Allier
  • offline

Message » 15 Mar 2014 15:29

thanks for your answer.
I know well that the 6600 is an excellent tweeter, but from the arrangements and datasheets have a different response measurement, as well as the angular dispersion.
therefore will play differently even if only slightly.
For example, the 6600 is the most sensitive part of 6620, only one db, but has a worse dispersion and is less linear extension
it would be interesting if someone had compared, mean tonally
gandalf_77
 
Messages: 12
Inscription Forum: 20 Fév 2005 11:36
  • offline

Message » 15 Mar 2014 16:40

I didn't listen to these two tweeters but at choice stage I would certainly take into consideration the use of the speaker, such as the axial listening spot and the effect of room characteristics in the high frequencies. The shape of the transfert function of the high-pass filter will certainly be the main reason of the listening result. :wink:

La configuration dans mon profil


En acoustique, l'analyse judicieuse des résultats de mesures nécessite la connaissance de leurs seuils d'audibilité.
Avatar de l’utilisateur
Agnostic1er
Superviseur Forum DIY
Superviseur Forum DIY
 
Messages: 11478
Inscription Forum: 19 Oct 2005 3:26
Localisation: Corrèze, à 500m de la Dordogne
  • offline

Message » 15 Mar 2014 18:59

Si cela peut aider ou demander l'avis de DenBret :
diy-enceintes/quel-tweeter-scan-speak-thdg-choisir-t30022782.html

Cordialement
Jean louis
jl dudu
 
Messages: 2358
Inscription Forum: 11 Nov 2004 22:09
  • offline

Message » 15 Mar 2014 19:17

thanks but I can not understand the comparison, I am looking for a real comparison
thanks
gandalf_77
 
Messages: 12
Inscription Forum: 20 Fév 2005 11:36
  • offline


Retourner vers Discussions Générales

 
  • Articles en relation
    Dernier message